Custom Orders

Small Batch Sugar Ink Custom Cookie Printing:

If you are specifically interested in our “Eddie” printed sugar cookies with edible ink – adding the perfect personalization for corporate gifts, weddings or party favors – please contact through the custom order button. These are available for pick up in larger quantities from our bake shop. Any logo, image, or message can be printed on them.

Each cookie starts at $4.

What is a custom order?

Orders with specific flavors, individual packaging or speciality tags, or that are larger in size (than the standard options above) are all considered custom.

Custom Order Options: Access the full menu here

• Muffins

• Scones

• Coffee carafes

• Cupcakes

• Individually packaged or bundled cookies

• Cookies by the dozen, more than 3 at a time

Choose from our delicious seasonal menu, and we’ll work with you to customize your order—from packaging and tags to personalized messaging. Reach out through the form below for more information and individual quotes based on your specific needs.

We can provide an electronic quote and invoice to get you on our baking schedule once the deposit is paid.

Please allow at least a 2-week window between when your invoice is paid and when the order is needed. During the peak holiday baking season, the more notice, the easier we can accommodate your order needs.

Cookie Club

Support Tablespoons by joining the sweetest club around! Sign up for a monthly subscription to our Cookie Club and enjoy a box 6-12 treats, plus a members-only handwritten note from an inclusive team member.

All orders go out a set week of the month and you can opt for free pick-up at our location, or local delivery and shipping for an additional fee for the full dozen. The half-dozen bundles are pick-up only.

Give back

Gift cards are also available at our sales counter for use in any in-person purchase. Give the gift that gives back to our mission!